Jack Marchant

The problem with Elixir Umbrella Apps

May 03, 2019

Umbrella apps are big projects that contain multiple mix projects. Using umbrella apps feels more like getting poked in the eye from an actual umbrella.

There are a few misconceptions about umbrella apps surrounding their purpose, how to effectively manage a growing project and deploying the app somewhere in production. I’d like to present a case for not using an umbrella app, if you were considering doing so.

A typical umbrella app

Umbrella apps are meant to help developers split different concerns into different apps thinking that a parallel can be drawn to a Service Oriented Architecture (i.e micro-services). An umbrella app can be thought about in terms of a single application, and in most cases is deployed as such.

Let’s think through an example app: In an application that has a web component serving traffic, type and resolver definitions for a graphql API, data contexts for interacting with the database, we could potentially have three apps in our umbrella:

We can still deploy this as a single project given the wonders of an umbrella app, and get some minor conveniences with config and testing. When a request comes in, the web app handles it, calling a resolver function in the graphql app, which in turn retrieved some data from the data app. The dependencies are in a single order: web -> graphql -> data, so when you compile it starts with the inner most dependency and works it’s way back, as you’d expect - however if everything is deployed together you can still technically access modules that are technically circular dependencies, which kind of breaks the separation concept.

What’s the problem with this application?

The main issue with this architecture is that the apps aren’t really split for the right reason. In a growing (in terms of code added over time) application it will most likely slow you down the more code you add as the boundaries become more brittle and blurred. The reason for this effect is that umbrella child apps are intended to be created as a way to deploy each of them separately, hence the individual configuration and mix project. So unless you’re deploying the apps separately, there is no benefit from using an umbrella app.

There may come a time when you need to, but I can guarantee moving into an umbrella app configuration, retrofitting on an existing app is the easier option than consolidating child apps.

Umbrella child apps are intended to be created as a way to deploy each of them separately

A better alternative

I’m not advocating to never use umbrella apps, but I think in most cases it’s better not to use one until you have the requirement to deploy a child app separately.

The alternative is to create a good old elixir application using ‘mix new’ and placing all of your apps into their own folders. You can still accomplish the same architecture without using an umbrella app and as a side bonus you’ll be able to quickly iterate and change your mind on decisions as you learn more about your business domain and perhaps elixir too! This is a much easier way to get started with Elixir, in fact Phoenix recommends to structure your apps in this way through contexts.

My experience with umbrella apps has mostly been one of trying to reduce its complexity and favour modules over apps.

In fact, in Elixir's official documentation where it explains some of the benefits of using Umbrella apps, it does state a disclaimer:

While it provides a degree of separation between applications, those applications are not fully decoupled, as they are assumed to share the same configuration and the same dependencies.

Maybe your experience has been different? If anyone has found success with umbrella apps I’d love to discuss it!


Written by Jack Marchant, a Software Engineer who writes about writing code. You should follow him on Twitter or check out his code on GitHub


using a dependency injection container to decouple code

June 03, 2020

Dependency Injection is the method of passing objects to another (usually during instantiation) to invert the dependency created when you use an object. A Container is often used as a collection of the objects used in your system, to achieve separation between usage and instantiation.

3 tips to help with working from home

April 17, 2020

Working from home has been thrust upon those lucky enough to still have a job. Many aren’t sure how to cope, some are trying to find ways to help them through the day. Make no mistake, this is not a normal remote working environment we find ourselves in, but nonetheless we should find ways to embrace it.

making software a three step process

April 14, 2020

One of the most useful tips that has guided much of my decision over the years has been this simple principle: three steps, executed in sequential order;

help me help you code review

October 24, 2019

Code Reviews are one of the easiest ways to help your team-mates. There are a number of benefits for both the reviewer and pull request author:

a pratical guide to test driven development

September 12, 2019

It’s been a while since I last wrote about why testing is important, but in this post I thought I would expand on that and talk about why not only unit testing is important, but how a full spectrum of automated tests can improve productivity, increase confidence pushing code and help keep users happy.

facade pattern

July 05, 2019

Design Patterns allow you to create abstractions that decouple sections of a codebase with the purpose of making a change to the code later a much easier process.

the problem with elixir umbrella apps

May 03, 2019

Umbrella apps are big projects that contain multiple mix projects. Using umbrella apps feels more like getting poked in the eye from an actual umbrella.

broken windows

April 14, 2019

Ever get the feeling that adding this "one little hack", a couple of lines of code, won't have much of an impact on the rest of the codebase? You think nothing of it and add it, convincing your team members it was the correct decision to get this new feature over the line. In theory, and generally speaking, I would kind of agree with doing it, but every hack is different so it's hard to paint them all with the same brush. If you've been doing software development for long enough you can see this kind of code coming from a mile away. It's the kind of code that can haunt your dreams if you're not careful.

lonestar elixir 2019

March 04, 2019

Last week was Lonestar ElixirConf 2019 held in Austin, Texas. The conference ran over 2 days and was the first Elixir conference I had been to.

genserver async concurrent tasks

February 01, 2019

In most cases I have found inter-process communication to be an unnecessary overhead for the work I have been doing. Although Elixir is known for this (along with Erlang), it really depends on what you’re trying to achieve and processes shouldn’t be spawned just for the fun of it. I have recently come across a scenario where I thought having a separate process be responsible for performing concurrent and asynchronous jobs would be the best way to approach the problem. In this article I will explain the problem and the solution.

best practices third party integrations

December 19, 2018

When we think about what an application does, it's typical to think of how it behaves in context of its dependencies. For example, we could say a ficticious application sync's data with a third-party CRM.

you might not need a genserver

November 20, 2018

When you're browsing your way through Elixir documentation or reading blog posts (like this one), there's no doubt you'll come across a GenServer. It is perhaps one of the most overused modules in the Elixir standard library, simply because it's a good teaching tool for abstractions around processes. It can be confusing though, to know when to reach for your friendly, neighbourhood GenServer.

offset cursor pagination

October 30, 2018

Typically in an application with a database, you might have more records than you can fit on a page or in a single result set from a query. When you or your users want to retrieve the next page of results, two common options for paginating data include:

protocols

September 26, 2018

Protocols are a way to implement polymorphism in Elixir. We can use it to apply a function to multiple object types or structured data types, which are specific to the object itself. There are two steps; defining a protocol in the form of function(s), and one or many implementations for that protocol.

exdocker

August 23, 2018

Recently, I've been writing a tonne of Elixir code, some Phoenix websites and a few other small Elixir applications. One thing that was bugging me every time I would create a new project is that I would want to add Docker to it either straight away because I knew there would be a dependency on Redis or Postgres etc, or halfway through a project and it would really slow down the speed at which I could hack something together.

working with tasks

July 26, 2018

While writing Understanding Concurrency in Elixir I started to grasp processes more than I have before. Working with them more closely has strengthened the concepts in my own mind.

understanding concurrency

July 14, 2018

Concurrency in Elixir is a big selling point for the language, but what does it really mean for the code that we write in Elixir? It all comes down to Processes. Thanks to the Erlang Virtual Machine, upon which Elixir is built, we can create process threads that aren't actual processes on your machine, but in the Erlang VM. This means that in an Elixir application we can create thousands of Erlang processes without the application skipping a beat.

composing ecto queries

July 06, 2018

Ecto is an Elixir library, which allows you to define schemas that map to database tables. It's a super light weight ORM, (Object-Relational Mapper) that allows you to define structs to represent data.

streaming datasets

June 27, 2018

We often think about Streaming as being the way we watch multimedia content such as video/audio. We press play and the content is bufferred and starts sending data over the wire. The client receiving the data will handle those packets and show the content, while at the same time requesting more data. Streaming has allowed us to consume large media content types such as tv shows or movies over the internet.

elixir queues

June 06, 2018

A Queue is a collection data structure, which uses the FIFO (First In, First Out) method. This means that when you add items to a queue, often called enqueuing, the item takes its place at the end of the queue. When you dequeue an item, we remove the item from the front of the queue.

composing plugs

March 23, 2018

Elixir is a functional language, so it’s no surprise that one of the main building blocks of the request-response cycle is the humble Plug. A Plug will take connection struct (see Plug.Conn) and return a new struct of the same type. It is this concept that allows you to join multiple plugs together, each with their own transformation on a Conn struct.

elixir supervision trees

February 06, 2018

A Supervision Tree in Elixir has quite a number of parallels to how developers using React think about a component tree. In this article I will attempt to describe parallel concepts between the two - and if you've used React and are interested in functional programming, it might prompt you to take a look at Elixir.

surviving tech debt

December 21, 2017

Technical debt is a potentially crippling disease that can take over your codebase without much warning. One day, you’re building features, the next, you struggle to untangle the mess you (or maybe your team) has created.

pattern matching elixir

August 15, 2017

Before being introduced to Elixir, a functional programming language built on top of Erlang, I had no idea what pattern matching was. Hopefully, by the end of this article you will have at least a rudimentary understanding of how awesome it is.

first impressions elixir

January 06, 2017

Elixir is a functional programming language based on Erlang. I’m told it’s very similar to Ruby, with a few tweaks and improvements to the developer experience and language syntax.

write unit tests

November 29, 2016

Unit testing can sometimes be a tricky subject no matter what language you’re writing in. There’s a few reasons for this: